All projects
BA thesis · University of Birmingham · written 1997, submitted March 1998 Joel Bailey · Draft for review

The Next Big Thing?

1997 2026

What a student thesis about techno got right, what it got wrong, and the thing it never said out loud.

2026 · a note from me

I was an American Studies student at Birmingham, spending the third year of a four-year degree at UCLA. I went because I could study film there for free (thanks, UK ). Alongside Hitchcock and the Russian documentary makers, I happened to be on the ground just as the American music industry decided techno was its next big product.

I took a few things into the thesis. A love of techno that started in 1992, when I bought Warp's first Artificial Intelligence compilation. A schooling at Birmingham's techno clubs later in the decade, The House of God and Atomic Jam. A big idea, that something was happening. And great dissertation supervisors in UCLA's ethnomusicology department: Cheryl Keyes, who knew hip-hop culture inside out, and Kimasi Browne, who by coincidence was doing his PhD on . Our theses kept crossing; more on that below. It got an , the highest mark the department had ever given. I didn't produce a crap piece of fandom!

Reading it again thirty years on, I can see three threads running through it:

  1. Real. What counts as real music.
  2. Road. Who controls how music travels.
  3. Roots. Whose music it is in the first place.

I followed the first two on purpose. The third I never said out loud, though the evidence is all there: techno is Black American music.

The crossfader

Below are its nine main ideas. Each one has a crossfader. Slide left for the 1997 argument, right for what has happened since, or leave it in the middle to read both.

All ideas at once
Before you read anything · four tracks, one question

01Where was this made?

Play each track, then pick the city you think it came from. The tracks open on YouTube; come back here to guess.

2026 · why this test is here

At UCLA in 1997 I played Derrick May's Strings of Life to an ethnomusicology class. Nobody in the room could believe it was Black music, the tutor included. (Sidebar 1: I was sat next to the DJ and producer Cut Chemist, from Jurassic 5, who was on the same course. He was surprised too.) These were people who studied where music comes from for a living, and they couldn't hear Detroit in it. I didn't put that in the thesis. I should have, because two of its threads were in that room at once: music made by machines can't be the real thing, and this can't be Black music. (Sidebar 2: Herbie Hancock was UCLA's artist in residence that year, I know! One day he walked into our class unannounced with a couple of heavies, sat down at a shitty upright piano, found the duff keys in seconds, played us a medley of his hits, and left.)

What ran through my thinking · then and now

02Three threads

Every idea below pulls on at least one of these. Tap a thread to light up the ideas it runs through.

The argument · nine ideas and a conclusion, in the order the thesis makes them

03Nine ideas

Words with a dotted underline open a quick translation, for anyone who wasn't there in 1997 or hasn't been near a club since.

Show
All three threads at once · history on repeat

04Fourth time round

In Chapter Two I quoted a BMG manager, John Preston, describing his business: take American inventions like rhythm and blues, "improve upon them", and export the winners back to the US. I called it cultural imperialism and moved on. It's a loop, and it's older than techno. By the time I was writing, it had come round four times:

  1. Pat Boone covering Little Richard, 1956.
  2. Elvis and Otis Blackwell, the same year.
  3. The British Invasion, 1964.
  4. Techno, sold back to America as 'electronica', 1997.

It has come round twice more since. Each time, the same three questions come up: what counts as real, who controls the road, and whose music it was.

Black American musicians invent a sound. The industry finds a white act to front it, often British. The record is sold back into America as the new thing. Most of the bands knew exactly where their music came from, and said so. The whitening was done by the business: labels, radio formats, marketing budgets.

1997 predictions, checked in 2026 · tap a row for the evidence

05Predictions scorecard

2026 · why this scorecard is here

I'm marking my own homework, in public. It would be easy to quote the predictions that came off and let the rest quietly drop out of sight, so every one is here, scored the same way, with the misses as plain as the hits. This is how I hold myself to account. If I only ever come out right, I'm not reading my younger self honestly, and nobody should trust the rest of the 2026 notes either.

Appendix 6 · the tape that went in with the thesis

06The music

2026 · about this tape

This started life as a mixtape. I made it to go with the thesis and handed it in with the dissertation, as Appendix 6. I can't find the cassette now. All that survives is my typed track listing, so the playlists below are rebuilt from that.

  • My 1997 cassette, side AThe compilation tape from the thesis appendix, rebuilt as a playlist. Track lists as I typed them in 1997, spellings and all.
    1. Yellow Magic Orchestra Mad Pierrot 1979 · Japan
    2. Kraftwerk Tour de France 1983 · France
    3. Africaa Bambaata Planet Rock 1988 · US (NY)
    4. Cybotron Clear 1988 · US (Detroit)
    5. Mayday Sinister 1989 · US (Detroit)
    6. New Order Blue Monday (remix*) 1989 · UK (Manchstr)
    7. Phuture Acid Trax 1988 · US (Chicago)
    8. Guy Called Gerald In the Beginning 1988 · UK (Manchstr)
    9. Rhythm is Rhythm Strings of Life 1987 · US (Detroit)
    10. Kenny Larkin Metropolis 1991 · US (Detroit)
    11. Eddie Flashin' Fowlkes OMU 1992 · US (Detroit)
    12. LFO LFO (album intro) 1990 · UK (Sheffield)
    13. Speedy J Pullover 1991 · Holland
    14. Frankie Knuckles Whistle Song 1991 · US (NY)
    15. Ron Trent Altered States 1990 · US (Chicago)
    16. D. May & Carl Craig Salsa Life 1990 · US (Detroit)
    17. Fuse vs LFO Loop 1991 · Canada/UK

    * New Order remix by Quincy Jones (US - LA)

  • My 1997 cassette, side BSame tape, other side.
    1. Eddie Flashin' Fowlkes Bust the Jam 1994 · US (Detroit)
    2. Scan 7 Black Moon Rising 1993 · US (Detroit)
    3. Galaxy 2 Galaxy High-Tech Jazz 1993 · US (Detroit)
    4. X103 Atlantis Acropolis 1993 · US (Detroit)
    5. Millsart Inner Self 1994 · US (Detroit)
    6. Mad Mike Final Frontier 1994 · US (Detroit)
    7. Advent Farencounter 1995 · UK (London)
    8. Damon Wilde Avion 1996 · UK (NY)
    9. Purpose Maker Alarms 1997 · US (Detroit)
    10. Purpose Maker Java 1996 · US (Detroit)
    11. Thomas Bangalter Outrun (x 2 copies) 1995 · France (Paris)
    12. Joey Beltram Ten Four 1995 · US (NY)
    13. Inner City Ahnonghay (remix*) 1995 · US (Detroit)
    14. Robert Armani Bouncing 1995 · US (Chicago)
    15. Surgeon Magneze 1995 · UK (Birmnghm)
    16. World Power Alliance The Seawolf 1992 · US (Detroit)
    17. Basic Channel Octaedre 1996 · ? Europe

    * Inner City remix by Dave Clarke (UK - Brighton)

2026 layer · the people who built it

07The people

Every musician and DJ named in my thesis or on its cassette, plus the ones it should have named, and a few who never made a record but made the scene. No photos here. They're the artists' and photographers' to license, not mine, so each card links out to where you can see them.

Send the attention back · where to go next

08Read more

  • SubmergeRecord shop, distributor, the Exhibit 3000 museum and the Underground Music Academy, still on the boulevard in Detroit. Buy from them directly.
  • Movement 2027Detroit's techno festival, Hart Plaza, 29 to 31 May 2027.
  • Kevin SaundersonHis 2025 editor's letter for Mixmag's Blackout series, on documenting techno's Black origins.
  • Assembling a Black Counter CultureDeForrest Brown Jr's 2022 history of techno, told from Detroit and Black industrial labour.
  • Detroit Sound ConservancyDetroit's music archive. Its Club Heaven collection keeps a piece of Ken Collier's sound system and the stories of the club around it.
  • Nightclubbing: House of GodRed Bull Music Academy's 2019 oral history of the Birmingham night, told by the people who ran it and danced at it.
Two-way decoder · for 20-year-olds and 50-year-olds

09Decoder

1997 words for anyone who wasn't there. 2026 words for anyone who was, and stopped going out.

Every 2026 claim, with where it came from

10Sources